Four Lessons
Temporary technical difficulties...resolved, finally.
Four things I learned on Saturday:
1. Brady Quinn is a little too muscular, has problems with accuracy, and rarely shows up in big games. At least, that's what I was told.
As soon as it became evident that Quinn would not go in the top ten of Saturday's NFL Draft -- a realization crystalized by his disappearance from the green room -- the 47 studio hosts on call at ESPN scrambled to tell me why he sucked. Which was funny, because those very same hosts and analysts had spent the two hours prior to his selection telling me, with video to back it up, that he was the second-best player in the draft.
This is not to knock Quinn, who did nothing other than set a gazillion passing records at Notre Dame and earn the admiration of Chaz Weis, who is adored by the ESPN brass. Rather, I was disgusted by the speed with which every one of those talking heads backtracked on Quinn once he dropped in the draft. Someday, if we're lucky, studio producers and talent will learn this one irrefutable fact about TV audiences: we don't care if you're wrong, as long as you explain the reasons behind your convictions, and then stand by them. "Transparency" is the word I'm looking for. I'll respect you if you admit that you blew it. Once you start re-writing history, you've lost me.
On that note, what does it say about the coverage of the draft when Keyshawn Johnson was far and away the best analyst on the desk? And how viciously will the South Florida fans rip the Dolphins for passing on Quinn? The Cleveland Browns just got the best offensive lineman in the draft, and the best pure QB in the draft. Nice work all the way around.
2. Tony Stewart has cojones milled from pure brass. His diatribe on NASCAR's "phantom cautions" hit a wee bit too close to home, but he barely scratched the surface. Back in the Dark Ages, when I was hosting "RPM2Night" on ESPN2, there was a running joke among the racing media about which team or driver would get "the call" before a race. The implication was that NASCAR would willingly and knowingly allow certain cars to slide through pre-race inspection -- a spoiler too high here, a roofline too low there -- based on who "deserved" a better shot at winning. Stewart's calling-out wasn't exactly the same thing, but it comes from the same set of criteria: put on the best show possible. It's entertainment, folks. Like wrestling. Crap, am I on probation?
But write this down -- the impending antitrust lawsuit against NASCAR will have much, much more to do with the future of the sport than anything Stewart can come up with. The dirty little secret of stock car racing is about to go public, and in my view, the France family's monopoly on venues cannot withstand the legal scrutiny.
Is there any scenario under which the NFL would be allowed to own and operate more than 50 percent of its teams' stadiums? What about the NBA? Wouldn't you be howling at the league's double-dip in terms of revenue? That's the reality of NASCAR right now. This is going to get ugly. Mark my words.
3. Straight beats long. Luke Donald assumed the lead at the EDS Byron Nelson in Dallas based primarily on his accuracy: through three rounds, he led the field in fairways hit, even though he was only 52nd in distance. He was also tied for second in greens in regulation. By comparison, first-round leader Sean O'Hair tumbled all the way to 28th in the field via a stat line that included the 9th-best distance off the tee and the 52nd-best average greens in regulation. Hit greens, make putts, win tournaments. Remember that before you plunk down 400 bucks for a new driver. That money might be better spent on lessons with the irons. Oh, and by the way -- the guy who ended up winning the tournament, Scott Verplank? Eighth on Tour in driving accuracy, 156th in driving distance. Career earnings: $19,410,000. Sorry, I was saying?
4. The Orlando Magic got exposed. When this NBA season began, I wondered in this space how many teams in the Eastern Conference were better than the Magic, and I predicted that they would make the playoffs. So far, so good. However, they were stripped naked in their first-round series with Detroit, in much the same way that Miami has been worn out by Chicago -- which I also predicted, in a roundabout fashion. The Magic have some big questions to answer this summer, and for once, it has nothing to do with a new arena. I've spent way too much time defending this franchise's decisions, on this blog and in person. This series was embarassing. Miami had an excuse, with Dwyane Wade playing on one arm. Orlando does not. Something has to change. I don't know that I completely agree with those who argue that the team needs a different voice, but I can at least acknowledge their stance. This, too, could get ugly, or perhaps it should.
Pretty good weekend for sports on TV, no?

2 Critiques:
Not sure if you saw the annual draft timeline, here's some of the lines on the day for the Dolphins and Quinn...
11:12 a.m. - ESPN analyst Ed Werder points out the Raiders are the only NFL team over the last ten years to not use a first round pick on a quarterback, running back, receiver, or tight end. Strangely enough, they also have no offensive team meetings, have no audibles, and their offensive playbook is merely the instruction manual from the 1989 video game "Tecmo Bowl."
11:41 a.m. - Steve Young describes the Browns upcoming pick of quarterback Brady Quinn as "making a huge statement."
11:42 a.m. - Cleveland selects offensive tackle Joe Thomas instead, leading Browns fans to make the huge statement of "@$%^@!".
12:29 p.m. - With Atlanta on the clock, ESPN treats it as a foregone conclusion that Brady Quinn will go with the following pick to Miami after the Dolphins two quarterbacks they picked up last year both failed horribly.
12:46 p.m. - ESPN shows a graphic of the Dolphins starting quarterbacks since the retirement of Dan Marino, including several players so obscure, Chris Berman does not have a joke for them.
12:51 p.m. - Steve Young finishes a five-minute testimonial for quarterback Brady Quinn, including highlights of his best throws, graphics of his abilities, and a haiku about his calm demeanor.
12:52 p.m. - A rare moment of unity is observed, as the Dolphins select receiver Ted Ginn instead of Quinn, and every sports fan in America loses their mind.
1:14 p.m. - ESPN's Suzy Kolber reveals that Brady Quinn has been taken away by NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell to a private suite, away from the television cameras broadcasting his disappointment.
1:15 p.m. - ESPN analysts Chris Berman and the frighteningly taut Steve Young both say that removing Quinn is "exactly the right thing to do," in spite of the fact that a) the only cameras broadcasting his sorrow belong to ESPN, and b) they just finished showing us a two-minute highlight reel of previously disappointed quarterbacks and their long, agonizing waits in front of a worldwide audience.
2:12 p.m. - ESPN spends two interview segments and ten minutes talking about how good Brady Quinn is, leading me to wonder why they don't just give him a job.
3:17 p.m. - Dallas Cowboys owner and riverboat gambler Jerry T. Jones, millionaire, swaps up a deal with Cleveland. The Browns get the pick to finally select quarterback Brady Quinn. Jones gets next year's pick from Cleveland, a second-round pick, an assistant coach, a '99 Ford Explorer, and two passes to the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.
3:25 p.m. - ESPN analysts talk about what a great story the ongoing torment of Brady Quinn has been, and how happy everybody is to see him drafted and on his way to a successful career. Everyone except Miami Dolphins fans, of course.
4:17 p.m. - The Saints choose 29th, after showing last year how a team could turn their season around by selecting the right quarterback in free agency and making the right first draft pick. Sadly, the Dolphins and Texans aren't paying attention, choosing instead to use this time to vote for their favorite "American Idol" contestants.
http://www.fistfulofsports.com/
5/03/2007 2:17 PM
Good stuff........
5/09/2007 6:25 PM
Post a Comment
<< Home